Close Menu
DISLAW Consulting & Mediation
Home > Staged Mediation

Staged Mediation

Some disputes call for a change in how a property, product, service, or organization works. In an ADA case, that might mean revising an accommodation policy and modifying a building entrance. In a construction or property insurance dispute, it might mean working out what repairs are needed and how they will be completed. Staged mediation can also help when a resolution may involve correcting a recurring property problem, fixing a technology system, or changing how a product is serviced.

For more than thirty years, I have represented clients in complex civil rights claims under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, the Americans with Disabilities Act, and the Fair Housing Act. Many of those cases involved requests for multiple changes to resolve a case. I found that a systematic approach helped clients make informed decisions. We could take the proposed changes one at a time, identify which mattered most, and ask what information would help us evaluate each one. I bring that experience to mediation as a neutral, helping each side understand the proposals and decide what it can agree to.

The parties may begin with very different views about whether a change is needed or what it should accomplish. Working in stages gives the people affected a chance to show how the problem arises and gives the people responsible for carrying out a change a chance to explain what it would take. A shared review, walkthrough, or test can focus the discussion and may reduce the expense of competing investigations. It can also give the parties room to develop solutions they hadn’t considered and build the working relationships they’ll need to carry out an agreement.

If the parties see a possible resolution, they can work through who will make each change, when it will happen, how they’ll know it works, and what they’ll do if it falls short. Where compensation is also at issue, it can be discussed as part of that broader resolution.

How Staged Mediation Works

Start with what each side is asking for

Each side can explain what it believes is happening, what it wants to see happen next, and what it disputes about the other side’s proposal. In an ADA matter, for example, one party may seek a change to an entrance or a service policy, while the other may dispute the need for the change or have concerns about feasibility. I help identify which questions are keeping the parties from evaluating a resolution.

Examples of Changes the Parties Can Explore

ADA, Civil Rights & Accessibility

A person who encounters a barrier can show where it occurs, and the organization can explain how the space or service operates. The parties might explore changes to a building entrance, an online transaction, or the way an accommodation request is handled. If a proposal takes shape, they can discuss who will carry it out, when it will be in place, and how they will verify that it improves access.

First-Party Property Insurance

When the parties are trying to work out how to restore damaged property, they may need to understand why two estimates describe different work. They can compare the scopes, discuss the order in which work would have to occur, and consider how to handle additional damage discovered during repairs. That discussion can inform a settlement while coverage questions and any applicable appraisal process are addressed separately.

Construction Defects & Incomplete Work

An owner and contractor may disagree about whether work meets the contract requirements or whether a proposed correction will hold up. A walkthrough or targeted inspection can help the parties compare repair options. If they consider an agreement for the contractor to return, they can discuss site access, completion dates, how the work will be inspected, and what happens if the repair falls short.

Construction Delays & Change Orders

On an active project, a resolution may require a revised schedule, a decision about disputed work, or a clearer process for approving changes. The parties can compare project records and discuss what needs to happen next, which work can proceed while other issues remain open, and who has authority to approve changes.

Business Interruption & Commercial Disputes

When the dispute concerns an ongoing interruption, the parties may need to work out how operations can resume. They can examine which repairs, replacement equipment, or service changes are needed, what can be done in the interim, and how to coordinate the transition back to normal operations.

Real Estate, Condominium & HOA Disputes

A recurring leak or drainage problem may involve several units, shared property, or areas controlled by different people. The parties can examine where the problem occurs and discuss who can authorize work, how contractors will get access, and who will respond if the condition returns.

Software & Technology Disputes

The parties can try to reproduce a failure and discuss what a corrected system would have to do. They might work out how a fix will be tested, who will review it before release, and what support will be available if the problem continues.

Environmental & Neighboring-Property Disputes

A dispute over runoff, odors, or another recurring condition may require corrective work and a way to tell whether it’s effective. The parties can discuss what to observe or measure, where and when to do it, and what results would call for additional action.